WWWNAREIT.com
Home REIT.com Contact Us Subscribe

 
 
 
Sector Spotlight
Lodging on the Mend: Less Room at the Inn
[January/February 2006]

By Art Gering

Lodging & Resorts
# of REITs 19
Market Cap.
(in thousands)
$18,208,637
Industry Market Cap.
(in thousands)
$333,935,637
% of industry 5.5%
Yield 4.1%
YTD Total Return 5.9%
One-Year Return 15.8%
Three-Year Return 35.1%
Five-Year Return 12.7%
Average Daily Trading
Volume (Shares)
6,867,133
Source: NAREIT. Data as of Nov. 30, 2005
The lodging industry has faced its share of challenges in recent years. However, the sector is showing signs of strength as both business and leisure travelers are coming back. With the economy continuing to improve and new supply remaining limited, lodging REITs are seeing an increase in room demand which analysts say bodes well for improved performance in 2006. In addition, demographic trends over the long term should continue to boost demand in the sector's favor.

PricewaterhouseCoopers forecasts lodging occupancy rates to advance 100 basis points to 64.2 percent in 2006. The average daily rate (ADR) is forecast to climb 5.1 percent, resulting in a 6.7 percent gain in revenue per available room (RevPAR). The firm also expects industry profits to rise from $21 billion in 2005 to $25.3 billion this year.

Last year, ADR increased 5.2 percent, accounting for most of an 8.3 percent jump in RevPAR. "ADR will continue to drive gains in RevPAR in 2006," says Maria Maslovsky, an analyst with Moody's Investors Service. "Gains in ADR are possible when competition is fairly limited, and in a strong demand environment."

Jan Freitag, vice president of Smith Travel Research, agrees, noting that significant ADR gains occur on the heels of the type of occupancy increases posted in the past two years. Smith Travel Research forecasts a 5.5 percent increase in ADR this year, citing steady demand from business and leisure travelers. In fact, demand growth is expected to offset supply growth by a fairly wide margin this year and beyond.

WHAT TO WATCH FOR: LODGING

As 2006 unfolds, investors in lodging REITs should be mindful of the following issues that could impact the sector’s performance:

Pros:
1. While more rooms are expected to be added to supply this year compared with 2005, supply growth remains very restrained.
2. Current expectations for a robust rate of GDP growth have favorable implications for lodging demand.
3. Leisure travel is expected to continue expanding at a healthy rate.

Cons:
1. The lodging sector tends to overbuild. Monitoring the pipeline of planned projects can provide an early warning of future overbuilding.
2. Greater inflation, driven partly by rising energy costs, could diminish leisure and business travel.
3. The diminished ability of consumers to extract wealth from their homes could significantly curtail consumer spending, especially on discretionary items such as travel and vacations.
Lodging Econometrics reported that the construction pipeline at the end of the third quarter of 2005 consisted of approximately 2,800 hotels containing more than 377,000 rooms. According to the firm, the project pipeline is 30 percent smaller than it was at its peak in 1998. What's more, new projects added to the pipeline in the third quarter marked the smallest quarterly increase in 2005, while project cancellations and postponements were at the highest level since 2003. Rising construction costs are one of the reasons given for a thinner pipeline.

Smith Travel Research also has been tracking the decline in new construction of hotels, and adds that the number of projects in the pre-planning, or "rumor," stage dropped 40 percent last year. "There is not even that much to talk about," Freitag says.

As if the decrease in the project pipeline were not enough, the existing stock of hotel rooms fell throughout 2005. Many rooms were removed either for conversion to residential use, or were simply demolished. At one point during the year, Smith Travel Research reported that inventory was reduced in 12 of the nation's top 25 markets, including New York City. A slowdown in new construction and the reduction of existing stock are drawing attention.

"You don't see supply ahead of the demand trend line until 2008 and 2009," observes Rod Petrik, a REIT analyst with Stifel, Nicolaus & Company.

Freitag concurs, but adds a note of caution. "The hotel industry has always overbuilt, and that will probably happen again because the industry has a short memory," he says.

Demographics and Inflation

Besides the supply trend tilting in favor of lodging property owners, leisure travel room demand during the next several years will likely be augmented by changing demographics. Room demand from leisure travelers surpassed business travel demand for the first time in 2004, according to D.K. Shifflet & Associates, and continues to expand. Leisure demand will be increasingly supported by the aging baby boomer generation, an age cohort that has accumulated wealth for years and will soon have the free time to spend it on leisure pursuits. The population of individuals aged 35 years to 64 years, a segment that includes baby boomers, is projected to expand 1.2 percent annually through 2010, compared with 0.9 percent for the entire population, according to data compiled by Marcus & Millichap Research Services.

Despite favorable supply and demand trends, an area of immediate concern for lodging property operators is the effect of inflation on travel. The yearlong rise in energy prices last year fanned talk of inflation. The consumer and producer price indexes, in addition to the bond market, were giving mixed signals late in the year, lending greater uncertainty to the inflation outlook.

The impact of higher inflation on consumer spending and travel could adversely impact the lodging business, cautions Daniel Michles, an analyst with Moody's. In fact, higher fuel costs are projected to raise business travel costs 12 percent this year, according to management consulting firm Runzheimer International.

As for the leisure travel segment, "there is a perception that the consumer is in a declining position to spend on discretionary items" such as travel, says William Crow, a senior vice president with Raymond James & Associates. "The perception is this will have a negative impact on lodging fundamentals."

Another potential risk for the lodging sector is an unforeseen downturn in the economy, Crow adds, and the sector's higher risk profile than other property types. "Occupancy goes to zero every morning," he says.

Lodging Stats

2002 2003 2004 2005* 2006*
Occupancy 59.0% 59.2% 61.3% 63.1% 64.3%
Average Daily Rate $82.80 $82.91 $86.24 $90.70 $95.21
RevPAR $48.86 $49.07 $52.90 $57.20 $61.25
Average Daily Rooms Sold (000s) 2,576 2,612 2,726 2,821 2,907
*Estimate ** Forecast
Source: PricewaterhouseCoopers

Lodging REITs Ready to Rise?

Despite strong property fundamentals, the performance of lodging REITs lagged for much of 2005 after a 32.4 percent total return was recorded in 2004, according to NAREIT data. As of Dec. 6, the sector's total return stood at 7.7 percent for the year. Still, the sector remains inexpensive compared to other property types, says Jeff Donnelly, the director of real estate equity research for Wachovia Securities. Stock valuations could edge higher in 2006 due to improving revenues and higher property values.

"Nationally, RevPAR is still 12 months to 18 months away from its prior peak," Donnelly states. "I would guess that EBITDA is three years away from reaching its past peak."

Additionally, the prices investors are paying for lodging properties continue to rise. "It's a sellers' market and there are more dollars chasing deals than there are deals available," Stifel, Nicolaus' Petrik says. "The deal marketplace is strong, which should be positive for property values, particularly as earnings increase."

Indeed, the median price of lodging assets valued at $1 million or more rose more than 30 percent last year to $73,000 per room, according to CoStar. But a vibrant investment market presents a conundrum, as REITs must decide whether optimal shareholder value is realized by selling assets at current prices, or whether accretive purchases can be made. Factors that will likely continue to drive the investment market this year include high replacement costs for lodging assets and a sizable pool of buyers intent upon converting properties to residential use.

Additionally, it should be noted that the largest agreed-upon deal of 2005 was Host Marriott's (NYSE: HMT) $4.1 billion acquisition of 38 properties from Starwood Hotels & Resorts (NYSE: HOT). The deal is expected to close in early 2006 and sets the bar for additional large-scale deals in the sector.

Lodging REIT Returns
Name Ticker Symbol Equity Market Cap* 2005 YTD Return
Boykin Lodging Company BOY 208,764 31.00%
Supertel Hospitality, Inc. SPPR 57,594 28.44%
Sunstone Hotel Investors, Inc. SHO 1,211,617 26.33%
Innkeepers USA Trust KPA 738,880 25.50%
Equity Inns, Inc. ENN 724,443 21.36%
MeriStar Hospitality Corporation MHX 854,266 17.25%
FelCor Lodging Trust Incorporated FCH 1,008,612 17.02%
Strategic Hotel Capital Inc. SLH 760,558 16.48%
LaSalle Hotel Properties LHO 1,008,555 9.04%
Host Marriott Corporation HMT 6,309,428 5.27%
Ashford Hospitality Trust Inc. AHT 443,157 3.05%
Highland Hospitality Corporation HIH 540,176 0.08%
Hospitality Properties Trust HPT 2,953,529 -5.62%
Winston Hotels Inc. WXH 264,717 -11.26%
PMC Commercial Trust PCC 132,602 -14.02%
Hersha Hospitality Trust HT 187,065 -14.97%
Eagle Hospitality Properties Corporation EHP 134,382 -19.15%
Not in index for entire period
DiamondRock Hospitality Company DRH 609,840
MHI Hospitality Corporation MDH 60,738
Source: NAREIT Data as of Nov. 30, 2005. *$ in millions

Besides raising capital from asset sales, lodging REITs continue to have access to the capital markets. Last year, lodging REITs raised $950 million in debt, $1.1 billion in secondary common and preferred equity, and $313 million in initial equity offerings.

"You're seeing a lot more secondary offerings," Petrik says. "In the near term, that probably will continue."

With property fundamentals strengthening, property values skyrocketing, and the capital markets willing to do business, things are going very well for the lodging sector. So, what does 2006 hold in store for lodging REITs?

"Now that lodging REITs are enjoying material positive cash flows, which has not happened since 2000, we want to see that cash flow applied to strengthening the balance sheet," Maslovsky of Moody's says. "A lot of lodging REITs are carrying material leverage, and some have significant secured leverage; we would be encouraged by seeing those levels reduced."

Others seem content to allow conditions to play out.

"Just like any other form of real estate, with lodging it comes down to supply and demand," Crow states. "From both perspectives today it's difficult to find anything but bullish statements about the sector."


Art Gering is a freelance writer and a senior market analyst with Marcus & Millichap Research Services in Phoenix.


Real Estate Portfolio® is the magazine for REITs and real estate investment.

It is published bimonthly by the National Association of Real Estate Investment Trusts® (NAREIT),
1875 I Street, NW, Suite 600, Washington, DC 20006–5413.
Phone 202-739-9400.